Turnkey Ice Cream Shop for Sale

Suffolk County, NY
Asking Price: $399,000
Business For Sale Details
Listed on Jan 9, 2026

LISTING ID # 37334

Semi-absentee, totally turnkey, neighborhood favorite ice cream and frozen yogurt store now available. Located in a high-end, high-traffic shopping center near national chains alongside well-known local businesses, the plaza is rapidly expanding with new tenants and the store occupies a beautiful space in a thriving retail environment that has been a community staple for over 13 years. This beautiful ice cream shop is known for its quality products and loyal customer base. The menu includes soft-serve and hand-scooped ice cream, frozen yogurt, and specialty offerings such as dairy-free, gluten-free, and fat-free options. Customers enjoy dozens of rotating flavors, along with milkshakes, acai bowls, smoothies, and a full coffee program featuring coffee, espresso, and cappuccino—delivering a true, full ice cream experience. The business is strategically located to support a strong, year-round clientele. It is especially well known for hosting children's birthday parties, completing over 100 parties annually with average tickets ranging from $500 to $1,200 per event. There is significant room for growth and expansion. Immediate upside exists through social media marketing and website enhancements. Additional revenue streams could be added by introducing donuts or bagels in the morning - there is currently no nearby bagel shop. A new owner could also expand into merchandise, a candy section, baked goods, or even a light lunch concept. With approximately 2,200 square feet, the space offers ample room to grow and diversify. The store includes a dedicated storage room, office, and restroom, along with an additional room suitable for installing ovens. A beautiful outdoor seating area further enhances the customer experience and increases capacity during peak seasons. Owner financing is available, and the current owner is willing to stay on temporarily provide training and ensure a smooth transition. There is also 1 full-time staff that will stay on as well. This is a rare opportunity to acquire a proven, well-loved dessert business with strong branding, repeat customers, and multiple expansion paths. This one will go fast - call today.

change currency

Financials (USD)

Asking Price $399,000

Cash Flow $140,000

Sales $636,000

Deal Terms

Represented by broker? Yes

Buyer Fee? Available On Request

Seller Financing? Available On Request

Willing to co-broke? No

Principals only? Yes

Franchise? Available On Request

Management will stay? Available On Request

Relocatable? Available On Request

Real Estate? Available On Request

Disclaimer: DealStream has not independently verified any of the information in this listing and makes no warranty as to its accuracy or completeness. This listing does not constitute an offer to sell, solicit or make an offer to buy an investment interest. Offers to sell, or the solicitation of offers to buy, any security can only be made through official offering documents, such as a subscription agreement and private placement memorandum. Read DealStream's Terms Of Use before responding to any listing. Learn how to stay safe in our marketplace.

Request Information

Want to learn more about this listing? Log in now. New to DealStream? Discover how artificial intelligence can help you find better deals! Sign up for a Free Account today and get your first Search Genius deal tomorrow.

Sign Up

DealStream Awards & Reviews

More Listings Like This
Resources For Entrepreneurs
Industry Guides