Top Convenience Stores for Sale in Nassau County, NY

Discover the best convenience stores for sale in Nassau County, New York with DealStream. Our curated listings span prime locations—from Hempstead and Oyster Bay to Glen Cove—offering turnkey operations, solid cash flow, and high-traffic opportunities for entrepreneurs and investors. Start browsing now to find your ideal Nassau County convenience store investment and connect directly with sellers for a seamless purchase.

All Matching Deals

Nassau County, NY

LISTING ID # 35861 This 30 years old convenience store is situated in a highly busy area on long island. The rent is $3590 a month, with a 10 years lease. The business has lotto, beet, an ATM, cigars,coffee, breakfast, and more. lotto earns $5700 in commission every month, while the ATM makes $800...

$240,000
Cash Flow: $151,000
Details
Branded Gas Station in Nassau County
Nassau County, NY

LISTING ID # 33091 This branded gas station is situated at one of the busiest routes on Long Island. Seller owns it for 27 years; wants to retire. Has a spacious convenience store and a 3 bays well-run repair shop. Due to a unique location, the profit margin on the gas is very high; sales of diesel...

$550,000
Cash Flow: $180,000
Details
Nassau County, NY

LISTING ID # 35282 This Smoke shop has been operating under the same name in the same area for over 28 years. The current owner has been running the business absentee for the last 12 months. Just finished refurbishing the entire store and then was confronted with a sudden business opportunity he...

$150,000
Details
Branded Gas Station for Sale in Nassau County, NY
Nassau County, NY

LISTING ID # 29975 This branded gas station is a part of a busy neighborhood in Nassau County. The seller has owned it for 20 years. It currently pumps 100,000 gallons a month. There is also a convenience store. Seller, for religious reasons, does not sell beer and/or lotto. Still, the store still...

$750,000
Cash Flow: $310,500
Details

Tips for Buying Convenience Stores In Nassau County, NY

Understand Local Market Dynamics

Before making any offers, it’s crucial to thoroughly research Nassau County’s retail environment. Look at neighborhood demographics, foot traffic patterns, and proximity to major schools, transportation hubs, or residential developments. Consider how local competition—including national chains—affects pricing, product selection, and customer loyalty. Understanding these local factors will help you gauge the store’s growth potential and anticipate any future challenges.

Perform Comprehensive Due Diligence

Request and review detailed financial records for at least the last three years, including profit and loss statements, tax returns, and cash flow reports. Make sure you confirm sales with third-party sources, such as credit card receipts or supplier invoices, since convenience stores often deal with significant cash transactions. Additionally, inspect the store’s physical condition and assess leases, licenses, and any existing vendor contracts to ensure there are no hidden liabilities or compliance issues.

Evaluate Operational Efficiency and Upside

Assess how the current owner manages inventory, staffing, and customer service. Ask about the technology used for point-of-sale, inventory tracking, and security systems, as modern convenience stores benefit from operational streamlining. Identify areas where you could quickly add value—such as by introducing new products, enhancing food and beverage options, implementing delivery or lottery sales, or leveraging digital marketing—to boost revenue and profitability shortly after acquisition.

Expand
Expand your search to all locations

You May Also Like...

Convenience Business for Sale in New York City
New York, NY

LISTING ID # 35047 This convenience store has been in the neighborhood for the past 20 years and is located on a very busy avenue in Manhattan. The store has a high volume of beers and smoking items. Presently runs 100% owner absentee, a hands-on buyer or team can greatly cut payroll and keep the...

$160,000
Cash Flow: $80,000
Details
Convenience Store for Sale in NYC
New York, NY

LISTING ID # 33918 This 25 years old convenience store is located in a very busy area of Manhattan. The store is laced with beer, ATM, cigarettes, magazines, coffee & breakfast, etc. Its gross sale is over $15,000 a week. The seller has a full time job, and has to travel abroad, frequently. The business...

$220,000
Cash Flow: $101,000
Details
Gas Station with C-store For Sale in New York
Bronx County, NY

LISTING ID # 35486 A branded gas station with a convenience store is situated at a bustling neighborhood in Bronx, NY. The store has lotto, beer, cigarettes, vapes, coffee & breakfast, etc. The business has a 10 years lease. It pumps 110,000 gallons a month, with a .25 cents profit margin on each...

$400,000
Cash Flow: $175,000
Details
Convenience Store Assets for Sale in New York
Westchester County, NY

LISTING ID # 36424 This convenience store has been open for only 2 months, but the owner has to move out of state and is no longer able to run it. It's now available as an asset sale and currently is operating with limited hours. This is a great opportunity in Westchester County, New York. A new...

$50,000
Details
Convenience Store for Sale in New York
Suffolk County, NY

LISTING ID # 37105 A 2,000 sq. ft. convenience store with all smoke shop items is situated in an extremely busy strip mall in Suffolk County, New York. Lotto makes $115,000 a year in Commission. The store does $45,000 in gross sales per month. The seller and his family are moving to another state....

$295,000
Cash Flow: $105,000
Details
Convenience Store for Sale in New York
Suffolk County, NY

LISTING ID # 35915 A 25 year old convenience store, fully equipped with smoke shop items, and a deli, is situated in a heavily populated neighborhood in Suffolk County, New York. It grosses over $50,000 a month; lotto makes $4500 a month in commission. The business sells a lot of smoke shop items...

$235,000
Cash Flow: $96,000
Details