Pizza Restaurants for Sale in Suffolk County, NY – Prime Listings

Discover prime pizza restaurants for sale in Suffolk County, NY, on DealStream’s leading marketplace. Whether you’re seeking a turnkey pizzeria in Huntington, a high-traffic pizza shop in Smithtown, or a family-run slice bar in Patchogue, our curated listings connect buyers with the best Long Island pizza business opportunities. Explore detailed financials, full equipment inventories, and owner financing options to find your perfect investment in New York’s booming pizza industry. Start your search today and own a slice of Suffolk County’s culinary scene!

All Matching Deals

Suffolk Pizza Gem 48 years-$260k Profit
Suffolk County, NY

If You Know, You Know... If You Don't, This is Your Golden Ticket. Broker is thrilled to present an extremely rare opportunity: the chance to acquire a legendary, highly profitable pizzeria and Italian restaurant in a prime Suffolk County location. First firing up its ovens 48 tears ago, this isn't...

$499,000
Cash Flow: $260,000
Details
Est. Suffolk Pizzeria with $190K Net Cash Flow
Suffolk County, NY

LISTING ID # 37191 This iconic pizzeria has been a staple in a bustling Suffolk County, New York strip mall for over 50 years, serving a polished and affluent neighborhood. With annual gross sales of $1.3 million and monthly rent of just $4,100, it enjoys a strong customer base supported by heavy...

$525,000
Cash Flow: $190,000
Details
High Volume Pizzeria For Sale in NY
Suffolk County, NY

LISTING ID # 36947 This is a fantastic opportunity to own a well-established, family-owned pizzeria located in a high-traffic shopping center with national chain tenants as neighbors. The business occupies 1,900 square feet and has been recently renovated, including a new cookline, making it a true...

$850,000
Cash Flow: $320,000
Details
High Volume Pizzeria for Sale in New York
Suffolk County, NY

LISTING ID # 36526 Profitable High-Volume Pizzeria with owner financing – Suffolk County, NY. Step into one of Suffolk County’s most established and consistently profitable pizzerias. This 3,000 sq. ft. operation is located in a prime, high-traffic shopping center surrounded by major anchors and...

$995,000
Cash Flow: $350,000
Details
Pizzeria and Restaurant for Sale in New York
Suffolk County, NY

LISTING ID # 36203 Newly listed in Westchester County, New York is a very well established and successful Italian restaurant and pizzeria. Having served the community for the last 40 years successfully. It is located on a very busy street with lots of traffic and is well known in the area. They have...

$599,000
Cash Flow: $340,000
Details
Pizza Restaurant For Sale in Suffolk County, NY
Suffolk County, NY

LISTING ID # 35427 This neighborhood pizzeria, with over 30 years of history and a strong reputation, is a fantastic opportunity for a hands-on operator looking to invest in an established business. Priced at $175,000 with a down payment of $125,000, the pizzeria generates gross revenues of $445,000...

$175,000
Cash Flow: $90,000
Details
Brand New Pizzeria for Sale in Suffolk County
Suffolk County, NY

Listing ID # 31858 Brand new 6 month old pizzeria in great location Cost over $300k to build front and rear entrance great parking lots of commercial and residential areas all around this store. Bagel store in these center does of the chart numbers. A new owner operator cold add deliveries or catering....

$225,000
Details
Ethnic Restaurant and Bar for Sale in New York
Suffolk County, NY

LISTING ID # 34849 This restaurant and full bar has been in this location for many years. This seller has owned it for just over one year, and finds there is not enough time to grow and scale this business. Pizza, Dominican, Mexican and American food all have a home here. Not too big but plenty of...

$180,000
Cash Flow: $40,000
Details
Lucrative Italian Restaurant for Sale in NY
Suffolk County, NY

LISTING ID # 34973 Now listed on the market is this high end Italian restaurant that is located in an affluent town on Long Island. This is one of the most highly rated and desirable Italian eateries & pizzerias on Long Island and for good cause. They serve a wide range of gourmet Italian cuisine...

$2,100,000
Cash Flow: $200,063
Details
Asset Sale Food Truck Business For Sale in NY
Suffolk County, NY

LISTING ID # 35275 There are 2 original well known and unique food trucks with trailer. These two gorgeous pieces of art work are big money makers and an even bigger attraction. One is a wood-fired brick oven pizza truck; the other is a gelato truck. The current owner has a large client list and...

$125,000
Details

Tips for Buying Pizza Restaurants In Suffolk County, NY

Understand the Local Market Dynamics

Suffolk County has a competitive and vibrant pizza restaurant scene, influenced by both long-standing neighborhood pizzerias and new gourmet concepts. Before making any offers, invest time in researching local consumer preferences, the busiest times of year, and your target customer base. Pay close attention to location-specific factors such as traffic patterns, nearby schools or offices, and competition within a one-mile radius. This deep dive into the local market will help you assess true revenue potential and identify any untapped opportunities.

Analyze Financials and Operational Efficiency

Thoroughly examine the financial records from the past three to five years. Focus on sales trends, food and labor costs, rent, and utility expenses, as well as the breakdown between dine-in, takeout, and delivery sales. Ask if the business uses third-party delivery services and what fees are involved. In Suffolk County, costs like insurance and local taxes can vary, so make sure these are accurately reflected in the profit and loss statements. Assess the operational systems—successful pizzerias usually have efficient kitchen workflows and reliable supply chains.

Plan for Transition and Growth

A smooth transition is crucial for retaining both staff and loyal customers. Develop a clear strategy to maintain recipe quality, customer service standards, and supplier relationships during the handover. Find out if the current owner is willing to provide post-sale training or support. Additionally, evaluate ways to grow the business, such as expanding menu offerings, improving marketing (especially online and on social media), and embracing technology for ordering and delivery. A strong plan for transition and growth can differentiate a good acquisition from a truly successful investment.