Find Pizza Restaurants for Sale in New York | DealStream

Discover Pizza Restaurants for Sale in New York: Whether you’re eyeing a bustling Manhattan pizzeria, a classic Brooklyn slice shop or a growing suburban eatery upstate, DealStream’s curated marketplace connects you with profitable pizza restaurant for sale listings across New York. Access in-depth financials, established customer bases and prime locations in one easy-to-navigate platform. Browse now to secure your next investment and take your place in New York’s legendary pizza industry.

All Matching Deals

Suffolk Pizza Gem 48 years-$260k Profit
Suffolk County, NY

If You Know, You Know... If You Don't, This is Your Golden Ticket. Broker is thrilled to present an extremely rare opportunity: the chance to acquire a legendary, highly profitable pizzeria and Italian restaurant in a prime Suffolk County location. First firing up its ovens 48 tears ago, this isn't...

$499,000
Cash Flow: $260,000
Details
Established Pizzeria for Sale in New York
Westchester County, NY

LISTING ID # 37053 Well established pizzeria in Westchester County, New York now available. Located in a high-traffic area near schools and public transportation, this pizzeria offers strong visibility and accessibility. The business maintains a balanced menu with approximately 50% of sales from...

$350,000
Cash Flow: $180,000
Details
Established Pizzeria for Sale in New York
Bronx County, NY

LISTING ID # 37071 Prime pizza parlor opportunity! Located in a bustling area, surrounded by schools, offices, medical buildings, police, and a fire station. This established pizza parlor is a goldmine waiting for a new operator. With an unbeatable rent at $3,050/month and a 13 year lease with the...

$120,000
Cash Flow: $88,400
Details
Established Pizzeria for Sale in New York
Westchester County, NY

LISTING ID # 37153 This well-established pizzeria in Westchester County, New York is now available. It is in a busy shopping center, near schools, and has served the community for over 8 years. The owner is ready to retire and pass this thriving pizzeria on. All equipment is modern, in excellent...

$179,000
Cash Flow: $105,000
Details
High-Traffic Pizzeria for Sale in New York
Westchester County, NY

LISTING ID # 37160 Don't miss this opportunity! An established pizzeria in Westchester County, New York is now available for sale in an exclusive neighborhood. This prime location sits on a busy street, close to school and public transportation, ensuring a steady flow of customers. This opportunity...

$199,000
Cash Flow: $80,000
Details
Established Pizzeria for Sale in New York
Queens County, NY

LISTING ID # 37177 Neighborhood pizzeria serving the community for 30 years with classic New York style pies and Italian favorites. The shop benefits from heavy foot traffic, schools, and retail stores nearby. Strong take-out, delivery, and dine-in business. Low rent lease with options and consistent...

$170,000
Cash Flow: $140,000
Details
Well Established Italian Restaurant
Orange County, NY

LISTING ID # 37253 This well-established ristorante and pizzeria, located in the heart of Orange County, New York, has proudly served the community for over 31 years, earning an excellent reputation and a loyal customer base. The spacious dining area comfortably seats approximately 66 guests, offering...

$525,000
Cash Flow: $185,000
Details
Highly Rated Pizzeria with Loyal Following
Westchester County, NY

LISTING ID # 37265 Owner financing available. This is a rare opportunity to acquire a highly successful, long-established pizzeria with 24 years of proven operation. Located in a prime, high-traffic shopping center surrounded by other established businesses and strong residential neighborhoods, this...

$625,000
Cash Flow: $250,000
Details
Pizzeria & Restaurant for Sale in New York
Westchester County, NY

LISTING ID # 37282 This well-established pizzeria in Westchester County, New York has been serving the community for 6 years and offers a strong foundation for a new owner to build upon. Known for quality food and steady customer traffic, the business benefits from a highly visible location and consistent...

$60,000
Cash Flow: $3,500
Details
Absentee-Run Pizzeria With Big Growth Potential
Westchester County, NY

LISTING ID # 37284 This modern pizzeria, located in Westchester County, New York, features an almost entirely brand-new buildout, with over $350,000 invested into the space. Currently operated on an absentee basis, the business offers significant growth potential for a hands-on owner who can devote...

$395,000
Cash Flow: $130,000
Details
Established Pizzeria for Sale in New York
Westchester County, NY

LISTING ID # 37285 This well-established restaurant and pizzeria, located in Westchester County, New York has been proudly serving the community for over 41 years. The owner has now decided to retire and the business is for sale. This is a great opportunity for anyone looking to step into a proven,...

$725,000
Cash Flow: $350,000
Details
Est. Suffolk Pizzeria with $190K Net Cash Flow
Suffolk County, NY

LISTING ID # 37191 This iconic pizzeria has been a staple in a bustling Suffolk County, New York strip mall for over 50 years, serving a polished and affluent neighborhood. With annual gross sales of $1.3 million and monthly rent of just $4,100, it enjoys a strong customer base supported by heavy...

$525,000
Cash Flow: $190,000
Details
High Volume Pizzeria for Sale in Rockland County
Rockland County, NY

Listing ID # 23146 High Volume Pizza Shop. Ideal for the Covid environment. Located in heart of upscale neighborhood in a very busy shopping center. Fully Equipped. Incredibly Clean and plenty of parking. Exterior facade newly improved. Turn Key opportunity. Perfect for an owner/operator. The business...

$550,000
Cash Flow: $210,000
Details
Pizza Pie Shop for Sale in New York
Nassau County, NY

LISTING ID # 36756 A well-established and beloved pizza shop specializing in authentic pizza pies such as Steak & Ale, Chicken & Leek, Steak & Kidney, Shepherd’s Pie, and Cottage Pie. In addition to its savory offerings, the shop features classic treats like bangers, rashers, candies, and crisps,...

$160,000
Cash Flow: $112,000
Details
Two Pizzeria's for Sale in New York
Nassau County, NY

LISTING ID # 36930 A rare opportunity to acquire two established pizzerias located in Nassau County, New York. Both locations are now available for purchase—offering a strategic multi-unit acquisition or the option to purchase individually. These well-known pizzerias have built strong local followings...

$545,000
Cash Flow: $112,000
Details
High Volume Pizzeria
Nassau County, NY

LISTING ID # 36262 High Volume Pizzeria-Restaurant. This is a beautiful and modern store that was beautifully remodeled by the current owners. They offer take-out and delivery as well as table service. The store is located on a main street in a very affluent area Nassau County. There is parking on...

$740,000
Cash Flow: $290,000
Details
High Volume Pizzeria For Sale in NY
Suffolk County, NY

LISTING ID # 36947 This is a fantastic opportunity to own a well-established, family-owned pizzeria located in a high-traffic shopping center with national chain tenants as neighbors. The business occupies 1,900 square feet and has been recently renovated, including a new cookline, making it a true...

$850,000
Cash Flow: $320,000
Details
Established Pizzeria for Sale in New York
Nassau County, NY

LISTING ID # 36503 This is a fantastic opportunity to own a well-established, highly regarded pizzeria located in a prime Nassau County, New York area. The seller is also willing to accept a cash price of $575,000. Known for its authentic Italian dishes and handcrafted pizzas, the pizzeria has been...

$700,000
Cash Flow: $416,000
Details
Profitable Pizzeria & Caterina Business for Sale
Dutchess County, NY

LISTING ID # 36692 This is a turnkey opportunity to own a well-established and highly profitable pizzeria in a prime location near multiple colleges. With a loyal student and local customer base, strong delivery partnerships, and a growing catering operation, this business generates $450,000 in gross...

$200,000
Cash Flow: $135,000
Details
Cattaraugus County, NY

Almost $1,000,000 in revenue. A rare opportunity to acquire a well-established, high-volume pizza restaurant operating under a strong brand. This location has been a community staple for years, serving a loyal customer base from along the busy Route 219 and Interstate 86 corridor. Business Highlights...

$110,000
Cash Flow: $51,000
Details
High Volume Pizzeria for Sale in New York
Suffolk County, NY

LISTING ID # 36526 Profitable High-Volume Pizzeria with owner financing – Suffolk County, NY. Step into one of Suffolk County’s most established and consistently profitable pizzerias. This 3,000 sq. ft. operation is located in a prime, high-traffic shopping center surrounded by major anchors and...

$995,000
Cash Flow: $350,000
Details
High-Volume Pizzeria in Manhattan
New York, NY

This established Manhattan pizzeria offers a rare opportunity to acquire a fully staffed, turnkey operation in a high-demand, fast-growing neighborhood with virtually no direct pizza competition. The business benefits from excellent foot traffic, strong online ordering, late-night demand, and a loyal...

$950,000
Cash Flow: $350,000
Details
Erie County, NY

Seller is retiring and looking for a new owner. Longstanding pizzeria and family dining restaurant available with the real estate included. This well-known local favorite has served the community for many years and enjoys a loyal customer base with steady dine-in and takeout sales. The property is well-maintained,...

$350,000
Cash Flow: $100,000
Details
Cattaraugus County, NY

Highly regarded pizzeria and family dining restaurant with decades of local recognition. This well-run business serves both loyal year-round customers and seasonal visitors in a vibrant destination community. The operation is fully staffed, well-equipped, and offers consistent revenue with room for...

$325,000
Cash Flow: $100,000
Details
Lucrative Italian Restaurant in NY
Westchester County, NY

LISTING ID # 35988 Profitable Italian restaurant in Westchester County, New York now available. Very well established restaurant has served the local community for over 40 years. New owner took over the restaurant a year ago, but due to a family situation has to sell. This restaurant is located near...

$895,000
Cash Flow: $475,000
Details

Tips for Buying Pizza Restaurants In New York

Understand Local Market Dynamics

Before purchasing a pizza restaurant in New York, it's essential to research the local market thoroughly. New York has a highly competitive pizza scene, with long-standing neighborhood favorites and continually emerging new concepts. Analyze foot traffic patterns, nearby competition, customer demographics, and delivery app trends in the neighborhood where the pizzeria operates. This local intelligence will help you identify potential opportunities and challenges unique to the area and avoid overpaying for a business in a saturated market.

Evaluate Financials and Operations Carefully

A successful acquisition starts with a deep dive into the restaurant’s financials and business operations. Obtain at least three years of profit and loss statements, balance sheets, and tax returns. Look for trends in sales, food and labor costs, and profit margins. Conduct thorough due diligence on lease agreements, kitchen equipment condition, vendor relationships, and staff retention. If possible, spend time observing peak hours and speaking with employees to identify operational strengths and weaknesses, which will inform your post-purchase strategy.

Assess Brand Value and Growth Potential

When buying a pizza restaurant, the value isn’t just in the ovens and ingredients—it’s in the brand and customer loyalty. Evaluate online reviews, social media presence, and word-of-mouth reputation. Consider whether the brand can be expanded to other locations, franchised, or diversified with complementary menu options. New York’s dynamic food scene rewards innovation, so look for opportunities to upgrade technology, refresh the menu, or enhance delivery services to boost sales and grow your investment after purchase.